By Charlotte Ndupuechi.
Keir Starmer’s resignation speech left me disappointed, not because he chose to step down—we all knew that was only a matter of time—but because he seemed unwilling to acknowledge how he arrived at this point.
During his leadership campaign, Starmer pledged to abolish tuition fees, supported public ownership of key utilities and championed ambitious green investment plans. Many of those commitments were later watered down, delayed or abandoned, contributing to a growing sense among voters that he had drifted away from the platform on which he was elected Labour leader.
What struck me most was the lack of personal responsibility. Starmer appeared keen to claim credit for successes while suggesting that failures belonged to the party or the circumstances around him. Yet leadership means owning mistakes as well as achievements.
There was no reflection on the controversy surrounding Peter Mandelson’s influence or repeated policy U-turns, including on winter fuel payments. Voters deserved some honesty about the decisions that damaged trust in him.
He also failed to address the impact of his earlier “island of strangers” comments. Although he later apologised for language that many felt echoed Enoch Powell’s divisive rhetoric, this was absent from his speech and for me was a concerning and controversial moment of his leadership.
Andy Burnham has built a reputation by delivering visible improvements to people’s daily lives. The franchising of bus services across Greater Manchester is a practical example of how political ideas can translate into tangible benefits for local communities. Whether people agree with all of his politics or not, there is a clear legacy taking shape—one that people can see for themselves.
I am not convinced history will look as kindly on Keir Starmer. His speech was a missed opportunity to explain how a leader who won such a commanding majority became so unpopular so quickly.
In Common is definitely NOT controlled by billionaires! We are currently crowdfunding to pay our annual bills and further running costs. For more information and to make a donation please click here.